Log in

No account? Create an account
Are you ready to be judged? [entries|friends|calendar]
:: The Icontest Judge ::

[ website | The Judge ]
[ userinfo | livejournal userinfo ]
[ calendar | livejournal calendar ]

its all about mcfly. take a look. [10 Aug 2006|06:31pm]
Do you like mcfly??
This site as things that you might like.
Filled with:

This site is updated at least everyday.
So click here http://groups.msn.com/marielovesdougie-/welcome.msnw


Ok. I think this will work. [24 Apr 2005|08:15pm]

[ mood | determined ]

SoI know there has been issues with the way things have gone around here recently. But I think this way will work-OOn

One judge gives their opinions on a icontest. The other three then have four days to add any additional comments or make their own judging as a comment, and then the community will be graded accordingly.

Is that OK?

6 went out to drink. :: Drink?

bishounenawards [24 Apr 2005|08:14pm]

[ mood | curious ]

Name: bishounenawards
About: An icon challenge for bishounen (a.k.a pretty Japanese boys in anime)
Special limitations? None.

Cut for the review!Collapse )

2 went out to drink. :: Drink?

Oh lordy. [21 Apr 2005|06:27pm]

[ mood | frustrated ]

The reviews were in last Sunday! I totally forgot! And Spring did too, oh dear.

For mods onlyCollapse )

6 went out to drink. :: Drink?

I_Animation Review [08 Apr 2005|05:21pm]
Well, this is my first review here, so please bear with me. ^^

Cut for length...Collapse )

So that's my first review here. waka_laka, if you'd like me to make a banner for this review and maybe for all future reviews, I can do that. That way we'd have generic banners for whatever grade a contest might get instead of having to make individual ones for everyone. Just say the word.
2 went out to drink. :: Drink?

OK! [08 Apr 2005|03:30pm]

[ mood | amused ]

Wow, this is late. I'm sorry. My computer broke. Anyway.

Since we had only three applications for judges, and there were three spaces available, then the three who applied are now automatically judges. So well done springhazsprung, painstakingly, and shiagurl! You have now been made into moderators and given posting access. So you can now see all the applications! Lucky you!

So, fellow mods, the first icontest to be judged will be i_animation. The grading will be done as A, B, C, etc. And I can't actually think of any other factors to judge, so I think we should stick to the four set out. But, if you can think of anything else, and it's glaringly important to mention about the community, I'd stick it in overall.

Let's see how this works. Post your reviews as a new post and try to have them done by Sunday 17th April. If you have any questions, comments or ideas, please comment to this post. I'm still a little unsure as to how this is going to work and would appreciate all the help I can get!

- Katie xx

3 went out to drink. :: Drink?

Ok, judges! [23 Mar 2005|02:15pm]

[ mood | accomplished ]

I now have an insane amount of icontest to judge, and the time to dither about the best way to judge them has run out.

So! I am going to make three more people judges. How do you become a judge? Well, you will have to make a review of your own so I can see how good a reviewer you actually are.

A good review means-

~ Looking at the whole picture.
~ Not being overly harsh. Even if you hate the community, say that in a constructive manner. Don't just be a bitch.
~ Don't limit yourself to being nice (I know I have to work on that!); if there is something wrong, say so. That's why we're judging.

If you want to be a fellow judge, then comment to this post with a review (in the same existing format as seen on the UserInfo). I'll then put it up to a public vote as to the next three. SInce my paid LJ is running out, I ask that all submissions are in by April 2nd. That gives you plenty of time, but if you need more please do tell me.

What icontest will you review, you cry? _angelicslayer_. SInce I am good friends with one of the mods, he won't mind us all using his community for this =D

Comments will not be screened- everyone will be able to see your review, so don't be shy, kiddies. Good luck everyone!

11 went out to drink. :: Drink?

OK, poll for y'all [20 Mar 2005|06:48pm]

[ mood | ditzy ]

Just to get your views. Please encourage lots of people to take this poll! It'll help me make this community better!

Poll #458033 Icontest Judge

What do you think should be done about the issue of judges?

Leave it as it is
More judges- all members can make their own reviews and post
More judges- only selected members can be judges

What else would you like to see added to/changed about this community?

Screencaps of the icontest
Grades like "A", "B" rather than "good" or "very good"
More factors to consider, i.e not just "layout", "punctualily"
More frequent updates
No banners given


Anything else you wanna say?

7 went out to drink. :: Drink?

Wow [17 Mar 2005|08:53pm]

[ mood | ecstatic ]

I have to say, great responses from all you icontest mods! Within two days I have had no less than six applications! That's three a day! Awesome!

I really hope this community gets as popular as I would like it to be. Maybe once we get enough members, we can open up the judging to everyone, and not just me, like painstakingly suggested. So encourage more people to join!

Also, if you do want your icontest judged, you don't have to be a member. But it would be nice, yo?

9 went out to drink. :: Drink?

carnivalecontst [17 Mar 2005|08:50pm]

Carnivale Icontest

Again, Carnivale = WTF in the dictonary that is my brain. I like learing all this new stuff =D

Cut for the judging!Collapse )
1 went out to drink. :: Drink?

degrassi_chorus [16 Mar 2005|02:20pm]

[ mood | bouncy ]

Degrassi Chorus

OK, I had never even heard of Degrassi before this. It looks pretty interesting though, maybe I should give it a glance over =D

Cut for the judging!Collapse )

3 went out to drink. :: Drink?

teh_andy [14 Mar 2005|10:46pm]

[ mood | chipper ]

Note: this is an example of how things will work. This is mine and my friends shared icon journal that's still starting up.

Teh AndyCollapse )


Apply here! [14 Mar 2010|10:45pm]

[ mood | amused ]

Comment here with your icontest link, what it's about and anything else you think I should know, hiatuses, etc. Good luck!

2 went out to drink. :: Drink?

[ viewing | most recent entries ]